Investor Guide
2026-10-10 09:45

Betriebspflicht (operating obligation): Without It, a Chain Can Close the Store and Keep Paying

A Betriebspflicht is a tenant's contractual duty to keep the store open and trading for the whole lease term. The law imposes no such duty: without a clause, a chain can close a supermarket and keep paying rent (§ 537(1) BGB) — the owner keeps the income but not the footfall or the property's value.

What it is

The tenant's main duty is to pay the agreed rent (§ 535(2) BGB). Not using the premises for a reason on its own side does not release it from paying (§ 537(1) BGB). A duty to trade arises only from the lease.
A standard-form clause requiring the store to stay open is, taken by itself, as a rule valid; so is a range-of-goods restriction, and so is an exclusion of competition protection. Only the combination of all three, with a narrow range of goods, is void (BGH, 26 February 2020, XII ZR 51/19, and 6 October 2021, XII ZR 11/20). A shopping-centre tenant that may neither close nor change its range is defenceless against a competitor the landlord is free to place next door. The duty can also be enforced in court: in the case decided in 2021, a regional court had ordered the tenant by interim injunction to reopen the shop.

Why it matters to investors

A closure without a payment default is a quiet risk. The rent keeps arriving, but the smaller tenants of a retail park lose their customers. At the end of the term the owner holds an empty building instead of a store with a sales history — and a weak hand in negotiating a new lease. Large chains close stores too: after the Real chain was sold in 2020, about 30 of its roughly 270 hypermarkets were due to close for lack of prospects (see Part 12 of the series German Prime Retail).
In our experience, the leading food chains are reluctant to accept a strict operating obligation for standalone stores: they value the freedom to close a weak store while continuing to pay. In a retail park, where the neighbours' footfall depends on the anchor, the clause is worth more. And if part of the rent is tied to turnover, a closure without an operating obligation cuts the rent to the minimum.

What to check

• Any operating obligation, the opening hours and the exceptions: refurbishment, reconstruction, force majeure.
• Its combination with a range-of-goods restriction and an exclusion of competition protection.
• The consequences of a breach: contractual penalty, termination right, interim injunction.
• Whether smaller tenants' leases depend on the anchor trading.
• The right to sublet: a change of operator can take the place of a closure.
Sources: BGB §§ 535, 537; BGH, judgments of 26 February 2020, XII ZR 51/19, and 6 October 2021, XII ZR 11/20; Gordon Real Estate Group, "German Prime Retail", Part 12; Gordon Real Estate Group transaction experience. Legal position as of 10 October 2026.
Photo: Amina Atar / Unsplash
This entry is general information and not legal or tax advice.