Investor Guide
A handshake over signed documents

Konkurrenzschutz (competition protection): It Binds the Landlord Even When the Lease Is Silent

Konkurrenzschutz is the landlord's duty to keep a tenant's direct competitor out of the other premises of its property and off its neighbouring plots. The Federal Court of Justice derives it from the lease itself, even without a specific clause, and treats a breach as a defect in the premises that can justify a rent reduction (§ 536(1) BGB).

What it is

Where premises are let for a particular business, granting their use under the lease (§ 535 BGB) includes keeping competing businesses out of other premises in the building and off the landlord's directly adjacent plots. This is implied competition protection (vertragsimmanenter Konkurrenzschutz). The landlord need not shield the tenant from all noticeable competition: the limits depend on the circumstances of the case. A breach of implied or express protection is a defect in the premises that can justify a rent reduction (§ 536(1) BGB; BGH, 10 October 2012, XII ZR 117/10).
The lease can widen the protection — with a list of protected ranges, a radius, a period — or narrow it; even a standard-form waiver is permissible in itself. But the Federal Court of Justice has drawn a limit (BGH, 26 February 2020, XII ZR 51/19, and 6 October 2021, XII ZR 11/20). Implied protection can apply in a shopping centre too, and excluding it by standard terms while imposing an operating obligation (Betriebspflicht) tied to a narrow range of goods unreasonably disadvantages the tenant and is void.

Why it matters to investors

The protection binds the landlord, not the market. Planning law is neutral towards competition, and a rival on someone else's plot across the road breaches no lease (see Part 5 of the series German Prime Retail).
What it does constrain is the owner's own letting. In a retail park, broad protection for the anchor can block letting neighbouring units to a discounter or a drugstore. Yet in our experience a drugstore, a supermarket and a discounter together draw the most visitors (Part 2). The wording therefore matters: whether it protects the core range or any overlapping goods.
Acquisitions carry the risk too. An investor that buys the plot next to its supermarket and lets the plot to a competitor may breach the first tenant's protection, which extends to the same landlord's directly adjacent plots. The consequence can be a rent reduction for as long as the breach lasts.

What to check

• Any competition-protection clause: which ranges of goods, what area, what period.
• Whether standard terms exclude the protection while imposing an operating obligation with a narrow range of goods.
• Who rents, or could rent, the same owner's neighbouring units and plots.
• Whether the anchor's protection prevents letting the rest of a retail park.
• Competitors' plans on other owners' plots: the lease offers no protection against them.
Sources: BGB §§ 535, 536; BGH, judgments of 10 October 2012, XII ZR 117/10, 26 February 2020, XII ZR 51/19, and 6 October 2021, XII ZR 11/20; BVerwG, decision of 10 July 2020, 4 BN 50.19; Gordon Real Estate Group, "German Prime Retail", Parts 2 and 5. Legal position as of 10 October 2026.
Photo: Amina Atar / Unsplash
This entry is general information and not legal or tax advice.