Investor Guide
2026-10-10 10:49

Discount Store as an Investment: The Plot Matters More Than the Building

A discount store's value depends not only on the tenant and the lease but on the plot: whether it lets the store grow by the time the lease is renewed. Germany's 15,976 discount stores average 1,287 m² of rental area, while the chains' requirements for new stores assume about 1,500 m² (BNP Paribas Real Estate). If the plot cannot hold the new format, the chain may move next door and leave the old building without a tenant.

Discounters have outgrown the 800 m² threshold

Discounters took 46.1% of German food-retail turnover in 2025 (EHI), and for years a single threshold set their size. These ALDI, Lidl, Netto and Penny stores, with a narrow range and simple fittings, were built with just under 800 m² of sales area: above that begins large-scale retail. Planning law permits it only in core areas or special zones if its effects on the surroundings are more than minor (§ 11(3) BauNVO; see Part 3 of the series German Prime Retail).
Today's formats have outgrown the threshold. Lidl looks for 1,000–1,400 m² of sales area, and the standard Netto store is designed for 800–1,200 m². In November 2025 ALDI Nord opened a store in Wolfsburg enlarged from about 800 to 1,300 m². Small formats remain for dense urban areas: Netto City occupies 400–799 m², Lidl's urban stores start at 600 m². BNP puts the missing area at about 250 m² per store on average and at 4 million m² nationwide, the equivalent of roughly 2,700 new stores.
Exhibit 1. The chains want plots of 2,000 to 6,000 m²: a store on a cramped plot is at risk at renewal
Chain
Stores in Germany
Sales area of a new store
Plot
Netto Marken-Discount
4,433
about 800–1,200 m²
from 4,500 m²
Lidl
more than 3,250
1,000–1,400 m²
from 2,000 m²; standard store (Basisfiliale) from 6,000 m²
ALDI Nord
about 2,200
from 800 m²
from 3,500 m²
Penny
2,122
500–1,000 m²
from 4,000 m²
ALDI Süd
about 2,000
not stated
standard store from 5,000 m²
Sources: chains' requirements for new sites and company data, 2025–2026.

The chains rent, own and sell their stores at the same time

An investor competes with the chains themselves for the best discount stores. ALDI Süd owns most of its stores; in 2023 it bought 76 of its own stores from Pimco for about €240 million. In 2024 Lidl sold 16 stores that it occupied itself to the fund Captiva for about €120 million, and in 2026 ALDI Nord is offering investors sale-and-leaseback deals. When a chain sells, it writes the lease terms, so the rent in such a deal should be checked against the market. In a Hahn Group sample of more than 700 food stores, discounters pay on average €12.37 per m² a month.

Discounters share the supermarket yield, and their main risk is relocation

BNP Paribas Real Estate does not separate the two formats: the yield for prime standalone supermarkets and discounters is 5.00% (Q3 2026). The price multiple is 18.5 times annual rent for a prime property and 15.5 for core-plus (2025). In our experience, a discounter lease runs for about 15 years with tenant options, indexes the rent only after a threshold and only in part, and leaves the roof and structure (Dach und Fach) with the landlord (see Part 10).
The format's main risk is relocation. If the plot cannot hold a store in the new format plus parking for 50–100 cars, the chain may build a new store nearby, and the old building will be left without a tenant. In our view, a discounter has a wider circle of potential successors than the large formats, but they too look above all for large plots.

Implications for investors

1. Judge the plot as rigorously as the tenant. By BNP's estimate, the average discount store is about 250 m² short of what the chains want. On a plot below the chain's minimum (Exhibit 1), a store is at risk at renewal: the chain may build a new store nearby.
2. Check whether the development plan lets the store pass 800 m². A store in the new format counts as large-scale retail, which is permitted only in core areas or special zones if its effects on the surroundings are more than minor.
3. Benchmark the rent when the chain itself is selling. In such a deal the seller writes the lease terms; the yardstick is the €12.37 per m² a month that discounters pay in the Hahn Group sample.
What to check:
• Compare the plot area with the chain's minimum (Exhibit 1), and check that there is room for an extension of about 250 m² and for parking.
• Check the sales area under the permit against the restrictions of the development plan, above all the 800 m² threshold.
• Establish which company of the chain signed the lease, how much of the term remains and what options the tenant holds.
• When buying from the chain itself, compare the rent with the market and read the terms of a future renewal.
• Look for new or planned competitor stores in the catchment area.
Sources: BNP Paribas Real Estate, grocery investment market reports for Germany, Q4 2024 and Q4 2025 (store counts based on HDE data), and retail investment market report, Q3 2026; EHI Retail Institute (as reported by Lebensmittel Rundschau, 3 September 2026); site requirements and company data of Lidl, ALDI Nord, ALDI SÜD, Netto Marken-Discount and Penny (expansion materials 2025–2026), EDEKA (report for 2025), REWE Group (financial report 2025) and Schwarz Gruppe (data for the 2025 financial year); ALDI Nord, press releases on the Wolfsburg store (November 2025) and for the EXPO REAL trade fair (September 2026); Lebensmittel Zeitung, 1 September 2023; Hahn Group, Retail Real Estate Report 2026/2027 (as reported by LEBENSMITTEL PRAXIS, 3 September 2026); BauNVO § 11(3); BVerwG, judgment of 24 November 2005, 4 C 10.04; German Prime Retail series, Parts 3 and 10; Gordon Real Estate Group experience.
Photo: Franki Chamaki / Unsplash
This page is general information and not investment, legal or tax advice.