Investor Guide
2026-10-10 09:50

Auswirkungsanalyse (impact analysis): Whose Turnover a New Store Will Take

An Auswirkungsanalyse, or Verträglichkeitsgutachten, is a consultants' report on which stores and town centres a new or enlarged retail project will take turnover from, and whether local supply will suffer. Whether a large supermarket may open or grow turns on the report, which also prices competition in advance: in Budenheim, the municipality's stores were forecast to lose 6% of turnover on average.

What it is

No statute names the report, but the rules' logic leads to it. Under § 11(3) sentences 1 and 2 BauNVO, a large store that can have more than minor effects may be built only in a core area (Kerngebiet) or a special zone (Sondergebiet). The effects concern local supply in the catchment, the central supply areas (zentrale Versorgungsbereiche) of its own and neighbouring municipalities, and traffic and the environment.
Above 1,200 m² of floor space such effects are presumed. The presumption can be rebutted either way in view of the municipality's structure, local supply and range of goods (sentences 3 and 4), usually by such a calculation. Neighbouring municipalities may invoke effects on their central supply areas (§ 2(2) BauGB), and a project without a development plan must not harm them (§ 34(3) BauGB).
The analysis defines the catchment and its purchasing power, forecasts the project's turnover and calculates the turnover diversion (Umsatzumverteilung): the share of sales existing stores will lose. There is no fixed percentage above which an effect is always harmful; the expected outflow of purchasing power can serve as the yardstick (BVerwG, 11 October 2007, 4 C 7.07). The model assumes the project creates no new purchasing power: all its turnover comes from others.
Exhibit 1. In Budenheim, a store of up to 800 m² would take up to €5.2 million of turnover from neighbours
Indicator
Value
Sales area of the project
up to 800 m²
Forecast annual turnover
up to €5.2 million
Population, 31 December 2024
8,786
Turnover to purchasing power, food and drugstore goods: now → after
about 66% → about 77%
Turnover loss for the municipality's stores
6% on average
Turnover loss in neighbouring Mainz-Mombach
2–3%
Source: BBE Handelsberatung, analysis for Budenheim (Rhineland-Palatinate), July 2025.

Why it matters to investors

The analysis is the most detailed external document on a store's catchment: purchasing power, competitors, their sales areas and turnover. It can also be public: Budenheim published it with the draft development plan for public participation (§ 3(2) BauGB). Tellingly, the project stays below the large-scale thresholds — up to 800 m² of sales area and 1,200 m² of floor space — yet still needed an analysis, commissioned by its initiator.
An existing store's owner learns more from other projects' analyses: they show in advance how much turnover the tenant would lose to a new store nearby. In Budenheim, the calculation has the existing REWE and Netto losing up to 6–7% of sales. Enlarging your own store needs a new analysis, and the logic that once protected the site may block the next format (see Part 5 of the series German Prime Retail).

What to check

• The analysis behind the current development plan, and what it permitted: sales area, range of goods, catchment.
• The assumptions — sales per m², purchasing power, competitors — and whether they are out of date.
• Analyses for other projects nearby, and the turnover loss they forecast for your tenant.
• Whether a new analysis would clear the format the tenant will want at renewal.
• The municipality's notices of draft development plans nearby (§ 3(2) BauGB).
Sources: BauNVO § 11(3); BauGB §§ 2, 3, 34; BVerwG, judgment of 11 October 2007, 4 C 7.07; BBE Handelsberatung GmbH, Auswirkungsanalyse zur geplanten Einzelhandelsentwicklung auf dem "Dyckerhoff-Gelände" in der Gemeinde Budenheim, July 2025; Gordon Real Estate Group, "German Prime Retail", Parts 3 and 5. Legal position as of 10 October 2026.
Photo: Lucas Kepner / Unsplash
This entry is general information and not legal or tax advice.