A Mietsicherheit secures the tenant's obligations: a cash deposit (Kaution), a bank guarantee or a parent-company guarantee. On a sale, the security passes to the buyer with the lease, as does the duty to return the deposit when the lease ends — whether or not the seller handed over the money (§ 566a BGB).
What it is
For housing, a deposit is capped at three months' rent excluding operating-cost advances; the tenant may pay it in three instalments, and it is kept apart from the landlord's assets, earning interest (§ 551 BGB). The rule does not reach commercial premises (§ 578 BGB): the lease sets the size and form of the security.
A guarantor undertakes to the creditor to answer for the debtor's obligation (§ 765 BGB). The guarantor's declaration must be in writing, and electronic form will not do (§ 766 BGB) — unless the guarantor is a merchant for whom the guarantee is a commercial transaction (§ 350 HGB). In our experience, leases require a guarantee as primary obligor (selbstschuldnerisch). Such a guarantor cannot insist that the landlord first try, and fail, to recover the debt from the tenant (§§ 771, 773(1) no. 1 BGB).
On a sale, the buyer steps into the rights and obligations attached to the security. If the tenant cannot recover it from the buyer when the lease ends, the former landlord also remains liable to return it (§§ 566a, 578(1) BGB).
Why it matters to investors
In our experience, the leading food chains usually give no security when a group company signs: their covenant is the security. The question arises when a subsidiary with a thin balance sheet or an independent merchant has signed (Part 2). Then a group guarantee turns the brand into a reliable debtor (see Part 7 of the series German Prime Retail).
In a purchase, the mechanics decide. A cash deposit must pass from the seller or be credited against the price; otherwise the buyer repays the tenant money it never received. The original guarantees go to the buyer, and they must not expire before the lease, or the final years go unsecured. Unlike housing, commercial premises have no cap, so the size of the security is open to negotiation at renewal too.
What to check
• The type, amount and term of each security, and whether a guarantee expires before the lease.
• The named beneficiary, how the rights pass to the buyer, and the original documents.
• The seller's transfer of the cash deposit, or its credit against the purchase price.
• A group guarantee, where a subsidiary or an independent merchant signed the lease.
• The form of the guarantee (§ 766 BGB), or the ground for the exception (§ 350 HGB).
Related terms: Ankermieter · Due Diligence · Gewerbemietvertrag
Sources: BGB §§ 551, 566a, 578, 765, 766, 771, 773; HGB § 350; Gordon Real Estate Group, "German Prime Retail", Parts 2 and 7; Gordon Real Estate Group transaction experience. Legal position as of 10 October 2026.
Photo: Amina Atar / Unsplash
This entry is general information and not legal or tax advice.